There is so much awesome in this film, I could go on for hours. But you'd all leave, so instead: a highlight reel.
The Writing
The writing in this film is absolutely fantastic. It's like a perpetual motion machine; absolutely everything you need to understand the plot is contained within the film.
Everything is foreshadowed;
everything is explained. But it's all done with a very light touch, so you generally don't realize,
hey, that's a clue! until the thing being foreshadowed has come to pass. At the same time, the script is relevant beyond its own borders; there's a lot of information about how Indians have been treated by the government, about reservation life, about what it means to be of mixed ancestry. And it's smart, smart writing. The dialogue is realistic, but still really lovely, and it does so much to describe the characters, and the setting. And it's funny! It's really funny; there are even jokes in Lakota.
Come on. Bilingual joking: does your fandom have it?
The Acting
Every role in this film is perfectly acted, which is amazing considering that a number of the actors -- including two of the principle actors -- were in their first roles. If you watch it
many, many times obsessively carefully, you can spot a lot of times where it would be so easy to push over into grand, melodramatic moments, but all the actors keep a tight rein on things. It's realistic, and so it feels more genuine.
The Directing
Everything in this movie is thoughtful. There are hundreds of fabulous details and really smart choices everywhere: in the set design, in the scene length, even in costuming.
Ray and Crow Horse's Inevitable Love
Thunderheart is too busy doing fifteen other things to be a love story, but the subtext is enormous. Sometimes it's so enormous, it stops being sub and moves right in to normal text. For example:
RAY: Hey Crow Horse. Fuck you.
CROW HORSE: Yeah, you'd love to.
I don't want to give too much away, but trust me: clearly they are made for each other. Their cranky, irreverent, banter-filled love? Awesome!